I would like to start out this post by thanking all who support the amazing work we do on Derosby Brothers.com. I hope that my comments do not anger you enough to avoid the work we do here on this site.

This morning I woke up to hear the news that Cliff Lee, the top free agent of this year’s baseball class, had signed a five year 120 dollar deal with the hated Philadelphia Philles. Of all the teams out there, I despise them them most, for their obnoxious attitude and their winning of the NL East year after year. They are successful and the results of their winning allow them to spend. It is a current situation of spending money to make money. They have built up a solid fan base and with each successful year, they bring in more money due to games, clothing, etc… That is why it is sometimes important to step up to the plate and spend the money when it is called for.
That being said, I must admit that this rotation is downright nasty, but only for the 2011 season. First of all, for those that know little about baseball, their rotation stands as
1. Roy Halladay
2 Cliff Lee
3. Cole Hammels
4. Roy Oswalt
5. Joe Blanton
That is a scary rotation as the top four can be an ace on almost all teams. However there is reason to worry at 2012 and beyond. First of all, the Phils rotation is expensive; very much so. They have two starters in their rotation making over 20 million dollars. And while Roy Halladay is a beast, he is still in his 30′s. Lee will be 33 when his contract begins, and with his contract having a 6 year in there or a 13 million dollar pay out, he will be 39 when it ends. Lee was ok this year, better in the postseason, He also struggled with back issues all year so I would be worried he would break down. Does that mean I would not sign him? Hell no, they were smart to do so.
The Phillies have an opportunity to have a rotation that rivals the 1990s Braves rotation of Maddux, Glavine, Smoltz, Avery, and Leibrandt. They were downright dominant and have three Hall of Famers in the rotation. Currently I would just say that Roy Halladay is a HOF, maybe Oswalt but I think the Astros team he was on will hurt his numbers. Cliff Lee, while good, is not HOF worthy, especially if Jack Morris isn’t in.
The Phillies farm system is in tatters. They have traded everyone away and have little left in the minors to bring up. The current starting 9, while good, is getting older. Utley has been dealing with injuries for the past year, Ibanez fought in the First World War, Rollins has slipped since is MVP season, and Ryan Howard will slowly make the Phils regret that contract.
Again, would I have signed Lee? Yes. Will they be hampered by huge contracts and an aging team in two or three years? Definitely. But they are built to win now. The only thing I could give for advice is that one day you will be like the Mets, tearing down a team that was built purely on money. The Mets are now having to stand pat as everyone, including the Phils get better. They have set aside a 5 million dollar spending limit; though Sandy Alderson says there is no limit. But after this year, they will drop almost $60 million dollars from their budget. Maybe they will spend smarter than before.

Now on to the Boston Red Sox. This winter they started by trading three prospects for Adrian Gonzalez. I think this is a good move, except his surgery, he should be a monster in Fenway. He is a great defensive infielder and a heavy hitter. He will give the Sox the hitter they have missed since Manny Ramirez. The major issue will be the length of the contract. Rumors are that it will be 160 for 7 years. That is a long contract and if he gets hurt or hits a downslide, like Vernon Wells, Alex Rios, and Carlos Beltran. That is a large hit it he fails or does not respond how Red Sox nation demands. But overall, this is a smart move. They are a big market club and they showed it.

The other contract worries me more. I like Carl Crawford and think he is a good player but is he worthy of being one of the highest paid players in the game? I am not so sure. He will make 142 over 6 years and play OF for the Sox. Crawford is very athletic and young. Those are two good components to have and a major reason they were willing to give both Gonzalez and Crawford contracts like that. However, Crawford is all about speed. He has stated that he is moving away from that. What happens if he has hamstring issues? Jose Reyes has been plagued by it and has become a major issue. I would be more concerned by this.
So in the end, I think they are all very smart moves, Crawford being the only suspect one. I like the Lee move but hope his back doesn’t go out in the first few years of the deal. In the fifth and six year, it does not matter. I think they will be an old club by then looking to rebuild. Sure they will have to sit on those deals until they run out, like Beltran, Perez, Castillo, but they will have a few more playoff appearances by then. The Sox made some great moves and have a strong lineup, but how will the pitching staff support them. Will Lackey, Beckett, and Dice-K make it back to form? Will the Phillies have enough bullpen help to keep those wins. The only thing I do not want to hear is that the Yankees only win championships by buying them. The Red Sox and Phillies just did the same thing. The Sox have bought or traded and paid for the following players: Gonzalez, Scutaro, Saltamacchia, Beckett, Lackey, Dice-K, Cameron, Crawford, JD Drew. Their homegrown talent is good but they have definitely used their Red Sox money to trade then pay for guys. The Phils whole rotation except Hammels is bought and paid for, including two 20 million dollar pitchers there. They have a homegrown infield, counting Pollanco for second run as a Phil, but that rotation is the key.
The key to success is to build talent, then trade it for major league players. Keeping minor leaguers, like the Royals, only equal to having great minor league teams. All the while, their major league club sucks, big time. So the Sox and Phils made some great moves, however no more crying when the Yankees sign the latest free agent by throwing money around. There is more than one guilty party there.
Now what do the New York Yankees do considering they planned on signing Lee, and maybe even Crawford. Crawford is an excellent Plan B, but his early signing hurt Brian Cashman’s chances of picking his second choice, if for some reason, Lee signed somewhere else. I think this will truly show if the Yankees just buy their talent or if Brian Cashman really is a good general manager. For years, I have said that one major attribute that few clubs had, except teams like the Yankees and Red Sox, was an ability to make their farm system look like the Garden of Eden. Every minor league player in each organization is a future HOF player. Teams are willing to trade with both clubs because they feel their lower, cheaper talent is better than in other organizations. However, teams like the Royals have major talent at the low levels but are never buyers, always sellers in the market.
Some of the steps taken by the Yankees are interesting, yet necessary. First of all, they signed Russel Martin to a one year deal. This ensures that Jorge Posada has likely seen his final days behind the plate, providing them with a power DH. The problem the Yanks have is that they have several of those exact players, as age is catching up to them.
The next player they signed is the oft injured, arm of a God-body of an old woman, pitcher Mark Prior.

This exact scene has been witnessed multiple times throughout his career. Just one look at the picture and I already know that we have a Prior and a trainer.
This is a low risk, high reward signing if he even comes close to reaching the potential he had out of college. Will he? I would not draft him in any fantasy league but one never knows.
So what do they do? I have heard the names Zack Greinke or Carlos Zambrano. Can they really handle the NY spotlight? I wouldn’t think so, quickly reviewing their past issues.
In the end, who really won here. Well in the short term both the Phils and Red Sox won. Teams like the Mets, while unhappy, are not as affected as one might think. They were not going to contend this year, as they do not currently have one ace, much less four. It hurts teams like the Tampa Bay Rays, who were torn apart by free agency and the lack of finances. It hurts teams like the Yankees and Blue Jays, who watched the Red Sox virtually take the AL Title. It hurts the Rangers, who now need a plan B in finding someone to replace the loss of Cliff Lee. It will be an interesting year, seeing how these contracts play out. But more importantly, it will be fun to look back, say four years from now, to see who really was most affected by these moves.
Most Recent Comments: